Design Goal (Quantified)

After a few more weeks of research and reading up I have decided to use deflection at the spindle as my primary design goal. I plan to use depth of cut (DOC) + width of cut (WOC) to estimate the acceptable deflection.

Depth of Cut

DOC in aluminum ranges from 0.254mm/0.76mm/1.6mm (Shapeoko Wiki) to 2.54mm (Vince Fab) and 6.35mm (Shapeoko Forum).

Recommendations for the Tormach PCNC1100 is also 6.35mm (CNC Zone).

WOC is recommended to be between 0.1 - 0.5 of the endmill diameter.

Cutting Force

There is a chart on the Shapeoko forum that says that a 500W spindle will see a force of 4.5N (Shapeoko Forum). This seems extremely conservative.

Using the Kennametal milling calculator, and 0.02mm feed per tooth (FPT or chipload), and 220/150 m/min cutting speed (SFM)

EndmillDOC (mm)WOC (mm)RPMMRR ($cm^3/min$)Force (N)Power (W)
6mm 2F631167184.0108.8710
6mm 2F431167156.072.5480
6mm 2F2.52.51167129.636.3230
6mm 2F60.61167128.043.5280
6mm 2F621193757.3108.8490
6mm 2F60.41193719.143.5200

It is interesting that a 2.5mm/2.5mm DOC/WOC has a higher MRR at a lower cutting force compared to 6mm/0.6mm DOC/WOC.

Endmill Deflection

The CNCcookbook recommends a maximum deflection of 20% of chipload. At 0.02mm FPT, that is a deflection of $0.004$ mm. They also recommend 0.025mm as a general guideline.

HSMAdvisor calculates 0.01mm tool deflection at the most aggressive cut of 6mm DOC 3mm WOC.

The Sienci LongMill has 0.2mm in y at 29.4N (Youtube).

FEA Simulation

Worst Case (110N)

X-AxisY-Axis
X-axis: 0.020 mmY-axis: 0.018 mm

Nominal (75N)

X-AxisY-Axis
X-axis: 0.013 mmY-axis: 0.013 mm

The V2 has 0.013 – 0.020 mm on x and 0.013 – 0.018 mm on y. Because I’m using “bonded” contact sets, the actual deflection is likely to be 2-3$\times$ more than the simulation.

This means the deflection under nominal load (0.03 – 0.04 mm) will exceed the CNCcookbook guideline of 0.025 mm.